The practice of converting black and white photographs to color in select parts for a creative effect has been met with varying opinions in the photography community. Some photographers and enthusiasts see it as a way to add depth and interest to an image, allowing the use of color to draw the viewer's eye to specific elements within the frame. This can be particularly effective in creating a sense of nostalgia or in highlighting the contrast between past and present.
On the other hand, there are those who believe that this technique can be distracting or even detract from the overall impact of the photograph. They argue that the use of color should be carefully considered and purposeful, and that adding it to a black and white image can appear gimmicky or overdone. Ultimately, the decision to incorporate color into a black and white photograph is a matter of personal preference and artistic vision, and can result in striking and memorable images when done well.